I want to buy a laptop... and I can't decide between a PC and a MAC. A MacBook will cost me $1,800 Canadian. Is it worth it?

3.0 stars
Forward

1 year, 2 months ago by Jeremy D.

45 Replies

  • Bradley P. Bradley P. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Yes, it is. A Mac will last you much longer than a PC would.
  • Truman K. Truman K. replied Jul 14, 2007
    depends on what you want to do with it
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Cheers guys,

    I'm going backpacking for a while. Wanted to bring along a computer... because I couldn't live without a computer for a year. I guess pictures, blogging, videos. That sort of stuff.

    It's just soo expensive.
  • Danil P. Danil P. replied Jul 14, 2007
    what? that doesn't make sense, PCs and Macs last the same amount of time, both use the same basic mechanics. Common thought is Macs are for the artists, PCs are for gaming. But then again, now that you have the portals that let you run Windows on Macs, doesn't really matter. Although I gotta say, Macs definitely look cooler than PCs
  • Patrick T. Patrick T. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Yes, it's most definitely worth getting a MAC
  • kishore d. kishore d. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Well it depends actually.. A mac is definetely more reliable compared to a pc.. If you are looking for a laptop to be replacable in about 1 or 2yrs than pc would be inexpensive.. but if you want to keep the laptop for a long time than mac would be the best
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Cheers! I really appreciate your guys' input.

    Thanks,
  • Eyal B. Eyal B. replied Jul 14, 2007
    I own an HP NC8430 Laptop, which I bought because it is very well built, and I can recommend it wholeheartedly.
    I thought about buying a mac, but they're way too expensive for their worth (you pay for the gadget feel).

    I recommend buying either ASUS (very well built), HP (only the NC series) or Thinkpads.
    It all depends on your budget, but anyway don't buy before going to:
    http://www.notebookrev...
    and checking the model.
    You can also post on their "what to buy" section, they are fantastic people, real enthusiasts and always help.
    Cheers,
    Eyal
  • Teri F. Teri F. replied Jul 14, 2007
    I just made the switch from PC to a Mac back in April. I love my Macbook and think the $1600 was well worth it. I'll never go back to a PC.
  • Thomas H. Thomas H. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Jeremy, I made the switch about 7 months or so ago. Definitely go for the Mac. It will be the best $1,800 you ever spend.
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Yeah, I'm starting to lean towards that decision.
  • G A. G A. replied Jul 14, 2007
    YES!!! PLEASE buy a Mac! It may be more expensive at first, but you'll throw more money at a PC in repairs in no time.
    I'm NEVER using another PC either.
  • Duncan H. Duncan H. replied Jul 14, 2007
    get a mac - you can run windows if you must - i installed parallels and xp on mine - have barely opened it since then. I only put it on to check websites in IE (yuk)
  • Brendan R. Brendan R. replied Jul 14, 2007
    a mac is made for what u need
    portability, pictures, videos, and easy to use ui
    get a mac!
  • Alyson A. Alyson A. replied Jul 14, 2007
    I got my mac about a year and a half ago..and it was completely worth it. I feel that it's a much more reliable computer with an easier interface...they're absolutely fabulous. I will never, ever go back to a PC.
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Ha ha wow this seems to be a really good advertisement for Macs ha ha. I bet apple would love this :P
  • Prashant S. Prashant S. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Go for a MacBook, I bought one a month ago and it's great! You will really like it if you buy one.
  • Aaron W. Aaron W. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Mac all the way!
  • Matthew B. Matthew B. replied Jul 14, 2007
    definitely mac :)
  • Riccardo E. Riccardo E. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Be different, get a mac!
  • taro m. taro m. replied Jul 14, 2007
    yeah be different like everyone else haha

    mac book pro. worth every penny.
  • 3.0 stars
    Aaron S. Aaron S. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Gah!
    Is no-one here *not* a fanboy?

    Answer these questions:
    1) What do you plan on using it for?
    2) Which OS are you most used to?
    3)What "extra" hardware are you planning on using with it?

    From those it'll be easier to guide your decision.
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    1) I plan on using it for editing pictures and videos, and working on my websites(s)
    2) I have never used MAC os before, and have been using windows since I was 12 (so 10 years)
    3) just a digital camera, maybe a wireless mouse
  • Connor W. Connor W. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Well if you enjoy games and near universal compatibility I'd say PC. As long as you're fairly savvy most of the normal pitfalls that are frequently commented upon don't apply.
    I have an HP Pavilion and absolutely love it. Got it for around $800. I've seen macbooks that have half the RAM, almost no graphics capabilities, a smaller screen and hardrive go for double that. Whereas I have not come upon a game I cannot run (I should even be able to play Crysis on, supposedly, medium) I have ample memory, and had leftover cash to buy things like a 500GB hardrive. Avoiding viruses isn't hard . You can get programs like avgfree for free, and run things like NoScripts, an ff extension. I also record TV and games straight to it with it's packed in Tv tuner, it even has an HDMI output, which is awesome for watching downloaded things more clearly on a much larger screen, or playing games.
    Obviously most here are fairly pro-mac, so I thought I'd share my own opposite opinion, hope it helps! ; )
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 14, 2007
    A comparable computer to the MacBook(that I could find) costs about $1400. I'm fairly computer savvy, and I've never had trouble with windows before.

    The main issue (and reason I am thinking about a MacBook) is that I am traveling and I need something reliable. If the MacBook really is less likely to break down, that's worth $400 to me because I wouldn't be able to send a computer in for repairs anyway.

    I'm not a big video game fan, but I spent a lot of time making and viewing media.
  • Alexander C. Alexander C. replied Jul 14, 2007
    Get a PC. IMHO, Mac OS is overrated, Windows is more compatible and more responsive, and if you get a decent brand it'll last at least as long as a MacBook (which has quite a few build quality issues).
  • Sean F. Sean F. replied Jul 15, 2007
    I drank the kool-aid, and you should too. Join us in the cult of Mac. The grass really is greener.
  • Danil P. Danil P. replied Jul 15, 2007
    go ubuntu ;)
  • Justin L. Justin L. replied Jul 15, 2007
    IMHO if you're looking for portability, battery life, and form factor, nothing beats Apple notebooks. I would suggest a MacBook just for that. I've owned and used several PC notebooks and own an iBook, PowerBook and a MacBook.

    iPhoto is nice for simple photo editing. I found iMovie very convenient, and iDvd very usefull for burning your movies into DVDs. I use all three for simple family movies.

    On quality, your mileage will vary. There's been a known problem with random reboots with the MacBook, search google on "macbook reboot problem". I personally have not had this problem. On the other hand I've known people who's had HDD crashes on Toshiba and Dell notebooks after less than a year of usage. My old iBook is now a brick only after two years of use. It would have cost me a min of $400 to repair. My PowerBook on the other hand has been dropped twice (no repairs necessary) and it's still running after 3 years. No problems with my MacBook, Hardware quality is hard to guarantee regardless of manufacturer...

    Summary: Quality depends on your luck as with any other manufacturer. But buy a MacBook - very light, great for travelling. Very long battery life, good for the airport, plane and coffee shops when a plug is not available. iLife comes with the whole package good for photos, movies, etc.

    just my 2 cents. I'll shut up now and go back to my bacardi.
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 15, 2007
    Cheers!
  • Prashant S. Prashant S. replied Jul 15, 2007
    Since you're going to be working a lot of graphic and media I suggest you buy yourself some more RAM when you get your MacBook (OS X loves it). I upgraded my laptop to 2GB and it flies!

    Moreover, I suggest you go to another store and buy it, Apple will charge you a lot more than the "normal" price, I managed to get 2GB for 100 euros :)
  • Justin L. Justin L. replied Jul 15, 2007
    I agree with Prashant about getting your RAM elsewhere. I talked to an apple store rep last year and she told me that RAM elsewhere outside of Apple is just as good and CHEAPER. She herself buys her RAM elsewhere.
  • Joe G. Joe G. replied Jul 15, 2007
    can't beat a mac, O drank the Jobs Kool Aid Years ago
  • Christopher W. Christopher W. replied Jul 15, 2007
    get a mac, it'll be the best decision of your life.
  • Anto R. Anto R. replied Jul 15, 2007
    if you have a Desktop WIN then get a MAC laptop
  • Phil W. Phil W. replied Jul 16, 2007
    Get a macbook! They're awesome.
  • Paris A. Paris A. replied Jul 16, 2007
    +1 MacBook!
  • Wannita P. Wannita P. replied Jul 16, 2007
    I agree with the common voice,I recently bought a macbook and its the best decision of my life. It makes it more fun to use and is way prettier on the eye. However, since its a Mac, it is more desirable to people when you go traveling and more "steal-able"- so if you're getting a Mac- guard it 24/7!
  • John T. John T. replied Jul 16, 2007
    Coming from a 24 Inch Imac user who also wants a Mac Book Pro. According to the rest of your replies, I believe the choice is already clear. But really people..... Was it a choice in the first place?
  • Thaddeus Q. Thaddeus Q. replied Jul 16, 2007
    If you're looking to save a little money on a mac, you can always buy them refurbished from apple- http://store.apple.com...

    Great way to save!
  • Jeremy D. Jeremy D. replied Jul 17, 2007
    You'll all be happy to know that I am buying a MacBook on Friday :P
  • nicholas w. nicholas w. replied Jul 18, 2007
    i would go with a mac, because mac makes great laptops, if not a mac, then tosiba. no gateway or dell/alienware
  • Christoph S. Christoph S. replied Jul 19, 2007
    Good to see that you'll be buying a Mac, I would have done the same. My next laptop will be a Mac
  • Davor P. Davor P. replied Jul 24, 2007
    Buy a mac, you wont regred a cent :-)
  • Shane C. Shane C. replied Jul 25, 2007
    Wait for the touch screen macs, I can't wait for a mac with the multitouch like the iphone

Join Now to Reply!

To add your own reply, sign in or join Pownce today!

401 Recipients

View all

This note is viewable by everyone.