Hm, difficult, but I'll have to go with Kevin.

Sorry Veronica, my vote is to Kevins..

!kevin

It was close, but I'm going to have to go with Kevin's.

I'm going with Veronica. Girl power!

Being that I'm a metalhead and all of that music is pussy, I'm going to go with the underdog so far. !veronica FTW

Kevin FTW! I am loving Muxtape.

!kevin

!veronica

sorry kevin gets my vote.

Its hard to beat Iron and Wine

Kevin's FTW

Going with Veronica. C'mon Kevin two songs from the same artist. Bad form on a short mix.

Kevin's FTW.

Sorry V, have to go with Kevin.

Veronic!

Yep, I'm with Kevin. Sam Beam is one of my favorites.

Kevin, agree about the doubling up on I&W, but great mix. My vote is for you.

Veronica's is much better. It starts with Neutral Milk Hotel, only serious muxtapers need apply. Sorry Kevin, pull one of those Rocky training montages and then try again.

I sure am diggin (no pun) on veronica's, on the other hand I haven't listen to yours quite yet...i'll get back to ya!

Veronica. (Not a big I&W fan. Yeah, I said it.)

Have to go with !kevin

kevins muxtape is way better!

!veronica , Andrew Bird & Neutral Milk Hotel are superb.

have to say Kevin's is more my speed -- particularity the LCD track

I don't know...I think the double I&W should be a disqualifier, but since that rule wasn't established, I will still give my vote to Kevin.

I vote Veronica

Sorry Kevin I am enjoying Veronicas a little more. Now I wait for the K fanboys to attack me.

!kevin , sorry !veronica but Iron & Wine and Bon Iver won me over

Kevin wins. Veronica's is too hipster-y. Kevin's is nice and mellow.

!kevin wins. !veronica 's is not bad too though. :-D

Veronica gets it for the Future Bible Heroes

While it may destroy my chances with the queen of the internet, yes I had a chance, I have to go with Kevin’s stuff.

Kevin, LCD Soundsystem - Someone Great, is an awesome song

@Veronica wins because she didn't duplicate a band.

Veronica's put me to sleep. Perhaps that is a good thing.

I'm going with Veronica's because Fiery Crash is an awesome song!

I would have to say kevins is better, but veronica has some nice songs tho.

Kevin Wins.... They both still need a little more Umphhh though...
http://robbobpenny.mux...

I love Iron and Wine, but I'm at work and need something more upbeat so !veronica wins this round

Kevin's got my vote, sorry Veronica!

I have to go with Veronica. I mean she is smart and hot!

Vote Veronica!

I say this is biased because it's on your pownce. I'll have to do the same post...

No brainer. !kevin

!kevin - Iron and Wine, and Diggnation are the best!!!

sadly based on looks and not sounds, it's Veronica

I like more of the songs in Kevin's muxtape, but I enjoy some of the songs in Veronica's playlist a lot more than I do any one song in Kevin's.

Veronica's Muxtape FTW!

I am going with Veronica. 'Future Bible Heroes' won it for her.

mmm.... veronic!.. but kevin have some good ones..

!Veronica for sure. Neutral Milk Hotel is amazing.

However, neither of you can touch mine: http://mobydick.muxtap...

I needed the hipster-y right now, so I'm going with !veronica at the moment, but I'll be buying from the !kevin

Gotta go with !veronica. I especially like the Neutral Milk Hotel track.

My vote goes to Veronica.

Best song ... Oh Comely
Best overall mix, Kevin's

I really like both lists but I'm gonna go with... Veronica!
I cannot vote against someone who added an Andrew Bird song, I just can't.

It has to be Veronica. She is way hotter, and has better taste in music.

I'm going with Veronica's with a thanks for the introduction to Neutral Milk Hotel.

Good call on Andrew Bird Veronica, but overall I prefer Kevin's list.

Oh, definitely Veronica.
Although of all Neutral Milk Hotel songs to go with, why "Oh Comely"?

Iron and Wine blew me away right out of the gate and carried right on through to Bon Iver. Sorry Veronica. Kevin's was closer to my tastes :: http://mikedowden.muxt...

Kevin wins that one sorry Veronica

BOTH OF YOU LOSE! I think all the songs suck.

I'll go with Veronica's for overall flow.

only five songs? I need more data before I can decide.

Close, but Kevin wins in a photo finish.

Definitely...Veronica's.

Abstain.
Neither mix tickled my fancy.
Must be the age difference.

Meh, not a huge fan of either, but I&W makes !Kevin win

*I* made a Muxtape, Check it out

IT BLOWS YOURS AWAY, ROSE!

http://bstolzberg.muxt...

It's Rose by a nose.

They are both good, but Veronica's is too soft.
MGMT+LCD Soundsystem > Neutral Milk Hotel + Andrew Bird

Also, I've never heard of Bon Iver, I like.

!kevin - I'm a huge Iron and Wine fan and loved the LCD Soundsystem song... cool list for both though

Iron and Wine will always prevail. Kevin wins!

!Veronica wins!!! Though I have to say Boy With a Coin is probably my favorite song last year.

!veronica - FBH ftw

Toss up, but I'll go with Veronica's

Im gonna have to vote for Veronica.

veronica

Veronica.

I'd have to say Veronica, for NMH, and not posting two songs from the same artist. -- http://seancarl.muxtap...

Veronica

Veronice. I'm in a mellow mood as it is late.

Veronica FTW

oooh. tough one. but Veronica included my absolute number 1 fav artist Andrew Bird so i'm gonna have to go with VB ftw!

!veronica
Veronicas was a bit better then Kevin...

Kevin's FTW

Veronica. Iron and Wine twice was the dealbreaker. I love I&W, but for a Muxtape, it should be more varied.

Veronica's today. Tomorrow?

Veronica for me.

Veronica has Neutral Milk Hotel so she wins.

I vote Veronica but if you want some hip hop, i created one since i was influenced by Kevin's twit and found the site.
http://elcapitan79.mux...

Kevins, just for that MGMT track.

I'm a huge Andrew Bird Fan - Sorry Kev. Veronica FTW

It's a no-brainer...Veronica.

!veronica

I want to vote V but K has it

Sorry Kevin.... Andrew Bird sealed it for me, my vote is for Veronica. Though both had great music.

my baby girl jammed a little more kevin. i think she"s a fan now.

Yours is probably better Kevin, both are good tho. =)

Easy peasy -> kevin.
Sorry, V

Have to go with Kevin on this one

This is a close one.

Enjoyed both, but Kevin wins.

It is a close call but I'm going with Kevin. It's like he's reading my mind!

Im going with Kevin...LCD SOUNDSYSTEM FTW!!!

As i send on twitter i'm calling it a tie, though i give +10 to coolness to V for The Cinematics track "Break"

Veronica's is more obscure but I gotta say even with doubling up the Iron & Wine I like Kevin's better. Including such a good Stephin Merritt song was almost enough to sway me though, Veronica.

I like 4 of Veronica's songs, while only 3 of Kevin's. Close, but it goes to Veronica!

I have to give it to Kevin. Sorry V.

/* Begin Shameless Self-Promotion */

$mines_better = "http://k00k.muxtape.com/";

/* End Shameless Self-Promotion */

Goin Kevin,

Not quite sure why we need muxtape. It has been a while but can you not just get one of the 3rd party apps. for myspace that allow you to upload as many songs as you want without any restrictions?

Muxtape seems to be marketing with a nostalgic allusion to 80's childhood.

My vote goes to Kevin

Veronica gets it for Future Bible Heroes.

Kevin it is.

Veronica FTW with Andrew Bird :D

Veronica...

Kevin's for sure

veronica pulled it out with The Cinematics

Veronica... Andrew Bird and NMH win it.

gonna go with !veronica, though LCD Soundsystem almost had me

I vote !kevin, the mgmt song was good.

Have to go with Kevin's "Iron & Wine" are sweet!! The track I liked the most on Veronica's was The Cinematics one

I'm going to vote for Kevin on this one.

It was very close for me. I didn't care for a couple of Veronica's songs while I found all of Kevin's songs pleasant enough.

Veronica. Two songs from the same artist is a bit redundant, even if they're both really good songs.

V gets my vote. I just enjoyed her mix more than K's.

Iron and wine, Kevin...

I like both and I just discovered some new artists - but the winner goes to Kevin. I love Iron & Wine

kevin

sorry !veronica
!kevin , 10?
Iron & Wine and Bon Iver won me over

sorry, veronica - too melancholy for today. !kevin, hands down.

Neutral Milk Hotel ftw!!! go veronica!!!!

im with Veronica, sorry kevin

almost went with veronica because The Mother Hips, but kevin pulled through with I&W, so im with kevin.

Kevin, no question

Veronica! NMH is great.

Sorry dude, enjoyed more of Veronica's mix.

Kevins muxtape comes in a close second......

to MINE!!
http://madmac66.muxtap...
or
http://djelectricdaddy...

yeah thats right, I did it :O

Kevin beats Veronica on this one!

kevin hands down, the bon iver got me. I can't believe so many people are into him now.

Kevin, for the MGMT and LCD.

Going to have to go with Veronica by the thinest of margins on this one. Can't wait for the best two out of three wager - let's up the ante you two.

kevin ftw

!Veronica

Kevin

I'm going with Veronica. Her songs were more tolerable to my tastes, even though I did really like Kevin's first song.

+1 for Kevin, right tone for the end of a hectic day

!veronica

I have to vote for Veronica. Kevin's was a little too mellow for me.

The Cinematics & Andrew Bird vs Iron & Wine and Bon Iver

LCD tips the vote for Kevin.

kevin wins out because his is a better MIX.
veronica's flow is way off... doesn't gel.

Gonna go with Veronica.

Kevin all the way man.

Love Iron & Wine, gotta vote Kevin

I WIN~!!!!!!!!!!

no, Kevin wins because the music is better...............

I was all set to vote for Veronica since we're both females .... but Kevin's really was better so Kevin gets my vote

My vote's for Veronica. Although I liked em both!

This is pretty good site
is this legal ?
is it owned by Amazon ?

I vote for Kevin sorry Veronica

MGMT is really great

oh damn, !veronica , I think I have the heavyweight mux championship!

Veronica - I even ended up buying the Cinematics

@kevin - Call / Raise / Fold ???

The one Kevin made is against the site rules so Veronica wins by default. Winning by default is the best possible way to win. I'll make my real choice after having a listen.

!keving , sorry veronica ;-)

!kevin

!veronica
Going to have to pick up whatever album I can find of the cinematics :p

!kevin came out swinging with an Iron & Wine combo, but !veronica ended the battle by firing back with a Neutral Milk uppercut.

Sorry Kevin but you can't win against someone who used a band that had a girl with a drum for a head on their album art.

Good mixes both..

I vote for Kevin.

Afterm my .02 now you can close the issue.... nothing like being prompt... My vote goes to Veronica... and thanks to the both of you for introducing me to some new(to me) music...